In terms of how homework should be utilized in a foreign
language class, it is important that the lesson is, again, reinforced and
highlights the most critical points of the day. Whether it is a writing
assignment or a simple worksheet, the assignment content should always be
relevant to what the students are learning about in class. If a teacher does
not give homework every day, perhaps it should be used as a study tool or extra
practice in case a student(s) is struggling but above all, it should be useful.
In my opinion, I suppose homework could be used improperly if it is just
busywork and doesn’t support any of the objectives for the course. One thing
that really bothers me is when teachers will assign challenging homework and
they do not even address it the next day in class. Essentially, if the homework
does not strengthen the students’ academic skills, it is probably useless.
I think that homework should be given both before and
after a lesson is taught. It’s not a bad idea to have students do an activity
that will introduce a new topic, even if they struggle through it or cannot
complete it. I remember in SPAN 632, we would have to research our next
discussion topic before we were introduced to it the next day in class. It was
great exercise because we already had an idea about what was going to be
discussed and researched before we had a chance to collaborate. Obviously, it
is more common to get homework after a lesson is taught so the students have an
opportunity to do the work correctly according to what they have learned. I
personally believe that if there is homework assigned before a lesson, it
should also be assigned after the lesson so students can see the changes they
made after they learn the information, or so they can expand on and change their
original thoughts/assumptions.
As for the video, I don’t think I would should my
students it because there are too many useless, vague suggestions for proper
studying habits. Realistically, not all of those things are essential for a
productive homework session. Everyone studies differently and all require a
certain, ideal environment to work efficiently. The best way to explain how to
properly get your homework done is probably through trial and error; if the
student realizes that they can’t get anything done with music on then they
should probably shut it off. Giving your students suggestions never hurt but it’s
a little unrealistic to say that all of those things lead to successful completion
of work.
I really like what you said about the possibility of homework being a study tool or extra practice if a student is struggling. I agree, homework does not need be assigned every day or every class, it just needs to be useful and it needs to support the work being done during class.
ReplyDeleteI think your idea that homework should be assigned both before and after an assignment could be more trouble than its worth. If you ask a student to do too much, they could become overwhelmed and the homework could detract from their learning experience. I agree that homework is necessary to reinforce, but I don't think that homework should be doing much teaching.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Mike in saying that giving homework before the lesson could become problematic. I understand that it would aid in introducing the new topics and students could come with questions, but if they are doing assignments with it, they could learn how to do it incorrectly, which in the long run could be harder to fix. Also, a lot of the times textbooks teach concepts in a manner different than the teacher presents it. In my experience, it is easier when the teacher teaches it so they can show you their tips and tricks to remembering irregulars, etc.
ReplyDeleteI also agree with Mike and Melanie. In my experience, especially in beginning language classes, whenever a teacher would assign homework about a topic that hadn't yet been taught, most of the students just ended up confused and we wasted more time in class the following day with the teacher reteaching the lesson and correcting our mistakes than would have been necessary had the teacher just taught the lesson and not required homework before it.
ReplyDelete